Fan Favorite Ice Cream & Custard Stops Around Ohio

March 15, 2024 MyOhioFun

We asked our followers to share their go-to ice cream spots around Ohio. Not only did they answer the call, they were passionate about their favorites.

Ice cream stops are listed by Ohio county and then by name. Please check back periodically, as we will continue to add submissions.

FAN FAVORITE ICE CREAM & CUSTARD STOPS

ASHTABULA COUNTY

Heavenly Creamery – 264 Sandusky St., Conneaut
Whip-n-Dip – 4840 OH-534, Geneva-on-the-Lake

CUYAHOGA COUNTY

Addicted Coffee Bar – 13743 Madison Ave., Lakewood
Brayson’s Ice Cream Parlor – 5840 Ridge Rd., Parma
Graeter’s – 10 Park Ave, Suite 116, Beachwood
Honey Hut -7304 Chippewa Rd., Brecksville
Mitchell’s Ice Cream – various locations

ERIE COUNTY

Granny Joe’s Ice Creamatorium (Toft’s) – 5598 Liberty St., Vermilion

FRANKLIN COUNTY

Johnson’s Real Ice Cream – 2728 E. Main St., Columbus

GREENE COUNTY

Young’s Jersey Dairy – 6880 Springfield-Xenia Rd., Yellow Springs

HANCOCK COUNTY

Dietsch Bros. – 1217 Tiffin Ave, Findlay

MAHONING COUNTY

Handel’s -various locations

MEDINA COUNTY

Bindinger’s – 410 College St., Wadsworth
School House Scoops – 686 Lafayette Rd., Medina
Skoops Homemade Custard Shop – 43 W. Main St., Seville, OH

MUSKINGUM COUNTY

Tom’s Ice Cream Bowl – 632 McIntire Ave., Zanesville

OTTAWA COUNTY

Toft’s Ice Cream Parlor – 4016 E. Harbor Rd., Port Clinton

PORTAGE COUNTY

Stoddard’s – 1321 W. Main St., Kent, OH 44240
Strickland’s Frozen Custard – 9070 State Rt. 14, Streetsboro
Vance’s Carriage House Creamery – 252 W, Main St., Ravenna

RICHLAND COUNTY

Kelly’s Dairy Bar – 1280 S. Main St., Mansfield
Munchies Dairy Bar – 460 Biscayne Dr., Mansfield
Whit’s Frozen Custard – 1531 Lexington Ave., Mansfield

STARK COUNTY

Almost Heaven Ice Cream – 624 Prospect Ave S., Hartville
Just Ice Cream – 213 Wabash Ave S., Brewster, OH
New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream – 14738 Ravenna Ave NE, Hartville

Pav’s Creamery – various locations
Taggert’s Ice Cream – 1401 Futon Rd. NW, Canton, OH

SUMMIT COUNTY

Country Maid Ice Cream – 3252 W, Streetsboro Rd., Richfield

Handel’s -various locations

Rosati’s – 95 E. Aurora Rd, Northfield

– Love when the flavor of the day is the Highbee Chocolate Malt. Daily flavors are listed on their website.

Skoops Ice Cream – 438 5th St. NE, Barberton, OH

Strickland’s Frozen Custard – 1809 Triplett Blvd. Akron

TRUMBULL COUNTY

Cockeye Creamery – 1805 1/2 Parkman Road NW, Warren, OH 44485

Sampled the Honey-Lavender flavor. So good.
The made to order ice cream sandwiches looked amazing. Next time.

WAYNE COUNTY

Orr Valley Creamery – 3004 Dover Rd., Wooster
Hartzler’s Family Dairy – 5454 Cleveland Rd., Wooster
Orr Valley Creamery – 1402 N. Main, Orrville

IF YOU WANT TO MAKE YOUR OWN ICE CREAM

We suggest you head to Ohio’s Amish County. Stop at Smucker’s in Orrville for toppings, then head to Lehman’s in Kidron to purchase an Ice Cream Maker.

Lehman’s
4779 Kidron Rd., Kidron, OH 44636
1.800.438.5346 |website

The J.M. Smucker Company Store and Café
333 Wadsworth Rd., Orrville, OH 44667 |website